When one thinks of Greer Garson, movies like "Mrs. Miniver" or "Pride and Prejudice" come to mind. MGM advertised The Valley of Decision as a “Tempestuous Romance” but watching the film you wouldn’t know this as the two leads in this film are super boring and artificial while all of the supporting characters take interest away from them. | How on earth this book is now out of print absolutely amazes me. The portrayal of steel workers along side the upper class was particularly interesting, because the owners are showed as observers and not really part of the sweat and steel, until Gregory Peck gives an awe inspiring speech about what its like working on the ground floor of a steel mill. Be the first one to write a review. Highly recommend! It wasn't so much you were watching a film, rather, you were entering & observing a particular person's life. Metacritic Reviews. It's as if, somewhere along the way, everyone lost enthusiasm for the project. The Valley of Decision gets 3 Stars although I had hoped for more. I am now 79 years of age and of course it is difficult for me to remember all the details of the film, but it was the style of film that impressed me so much that I have been looking for it ever since. Only Lionel Barrymore as Mary's bitter father manages to wreck things with his usual ham overacting. Mary's father is Patrick Rafferty (Lionel Barrymore), who is extremely bitter after having lost the use of his legs due to a mill accident. "The Valley of Decision" (1945) stars two of Hollywood's finest actors; Greer Garson and Gregory Peck. Garson was nominated five years in a row from 1941-45, tying the record previously set by Bette Davis. No, my purpose here, and in most of my other reviews, is to take a look at other aspects of the movie, such as acting, writing, etc. Specifically, he blames the mill owner's family (the Scotts) for his loss. They make a terrific acting pair, at the peak of their careers, and ignite the screen with passionate intensity. This movie is a must-see for all movie fans. I'd heard about how Peck was one of the few hunks left at home during WWII but was not as familiar with Miss Garson except for perhaps Goodbye Mr. Chips. With the exception of 1940, Miss Garson was nominated for best actress from 1939-1945, a Hollywood record. And I am glad I did, as the powerful plot unfolded in unexpected ways. You can still see all customer reviews for the product. It was bought for the woman who was probably their biggest female star at the time Greer Garson. Mary's service at home is paralleled by the military service of the men in the book and by the mill's contribution to various war efforts. Reviews There are no reviews yet. Directed by Tay Garnett and boasting a screenplay by Sonya Levien (Interrupted Melody (1955)) and John Meehan (Boys Town (1938)) this above average drama features an all-star cast which includes Greer Garson (Mrs. Miniver (1942)) Gregory Peck (To Kill a Mockingbird (1962)) Donald Crisp (How Green Was My Valley (1941)) Lionel Barrymore (A … Every single girl in my class read it & I was the last to get it. You could already see the Atticus Finch in him. Movie Info An Irish maid, Mary Rafferty (Greer Garson), falls for Paul (Gregory Peck), who is the son of her rich boss, William Scott (Donald Crisp). This is a fine historical-era drama, about a Pennsylvania mill-town. Greer Garson is a phenomenal actress, who portrays her role in such a real way, that it's almost like you knew her, as she went thru her life. The valley of decision by Davenport, Marcia, 1903-1996. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Valley of Decision at Amazon.com. It has all the essential elements, that so many movies of this generation are lacking; and therefore, could take notes of the ones in this film. I came across this book by accident after my grandfather died as I was searching through his books. Altho, I have just seen this movie for the first time, I know it is one that ought to be cherished for generations to come. And when one thinks of Gregory Peck, movies like "To Kill a Mockingbird" or "Gentleman's Agreement" come to mind. "The Valley of Decision" received two Oscar nominations in 1945, Best Actress (Greer Garson) and Best Dramatic or Comedy Score. Garson plays with charming capability the Irish servant Mary to the Scott scion Peck against the backdrop of a Pittsburg steel mill. Rather dated but still good light reading. I do not recall ordering or buying this item. This film is one of those epic stories chopped down into something you can simply enjoy in one evening. It is he who begets violence that has tragic consequences. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. What a great movie where determination and love of the steel mills helped preserve and shape the USA into a world power. Reviews of The Valley of Decision. Nevertheless, I was captivated by this one. The Valley Of Decision $ 5.95 – $ 11.95 An Irish maid falls for the son of her wealthy boss, though their disapproving fathers and a bitter strike at the steel mill complicates matters. This is always an attractive and a carefully-considered production, which occasionally seems to me to lack warmth; with a great script, everyone concerned could perhaps have produced a masterpiece. While some of the book's patriotism appears simplistic to the point of jingoism, not to say mawkishness, the final section, which shifts the focus to journalist Claire's experiences in 1930s central Europe, contains a powerful anti-isolationist argument in the form of a graphic account of the horrors of the Nazi invasion of Czechoslovakia. Something about old films and the way the predictability does not inhibit viewing enjoyment. When I say that the art direction was done by Cedric Gibbons with Paul Groesse, the set decorations by Edwin B. Willis and the costume designs by Irene, I have accounted for the film's very-opulent and vivid production values. Gregory Peck turns in his usual excellent performance as Paul Scott, the son of a wealthy steel mill owner (Donald Crisp), who falls in love with Mary (Greer Garson), the hired housekeeper. I would love to see it redone, with another fine cast; more than melodrama, it has I believe as a writer, an important dramatic potential. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 10 April 2011. The acting was superb and the performances by Greer Garson and Gregory Peck were both fantastic as well as nice performances by the supporting actresses Marsha Hunt (Constance Scott) and Gladys Cooper (Clarissa Scott). I loved Greer Garson in Mrs. Miniver, and again, in The Valley of Decision she gives another outstanding performance. Gregory Peck is a real man who falls in love with a feminine woman. The skimpy backlot work and the really wretched art direction (at least for a prestige M-G-M picture) were appalling. This very well performed movie, starring the beautiful Greer Garson and the debonair Gregory Peck is virtually inaudible throughout the film. The definitive site for Reviews, Trailers, Showtimes, and Tickets . I found both of them believable as they struggled with their feelings for each other amidst family feuds and class bigotry. Having the likes of Greer Garson ('Mrs Miniver'), Gregory Peck ('To Kill a Mockingbird'), 'Lionel Barrymore ('It's a Wonderful Life'), Donald Crisp ('How Green Was My Valley'), Marsha Hunt ('Pride and Prejudice'), Gladys Cooper ('Now Voyager', but so many fine films to choose from) and Jessica Tandy ('Driving Miss Daisy') in the same film, having them individually in a film was great enough, promised so much. Also, I am more a fan of Warner Brothers films than the glossy MGM fare. Check out DrakeBullet's 7/10 review of "The Valley of Decision" Oscars Best Picture Winners Best Picture Winners Golden Globes Emmys STARmeter Awards San Diego Comic-Con New York Comic-Con Sundance Film Festival Toronto Int'l Film Festival Awards Central Festival Central All Events The movie is primarily hampered by the lack of chemistry between its two main stars. This movie is full of anxiety ridden romance and dramatic acting at its best. The chemistry between Gregory Peck and Greer!!! I sat in awe of this film one chilly October evening in 2001 and I remember the thought going through my mind, "how is it that I've never seen this before?" Davenport, an American, was apparently close to Jan Masaryk, the Czechoslovak Foreign Minister who was defenestrated in Prague in 1948. Inevitably, Greer and Gregory Peck (as the principled second son of the family) find themselves drawn to each other despite class differences, and surprisingly, his parents spprove. This movie is a treasure. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 3 August 2009 "The Valley of Decision" is Edith Wharton's first long novel, being published in 1902 after her two collections of shorter works, "The Greater Inclination" and "Crucial Instances", and the novella "The Touchstone". (The irresponsible 1920s, the period with which the book is least in sympathy, are covered in a token chapter). Click and Collect from your local Waterstones or get FREE UK delivery on orders over £25. This book instilled my love of reading & for the rest of my life I have read 2/3 books each week - many of which were excellent but none has ever came up to the excellent ccontent of this book. 2 Favorites . The Valley of Decision is a 1945 film directed by Tay Garnett, based on Marcia Davenport's 1942 novel of the same name. Their chemistry comes through the screen. Gladys Cooper plays the matriarch of the family, who befriends Garson, and leaves her her shares in the mill. It is no surprise that Garson was nominated for her performance and all of the players were well cast for their respective roles. The cast of characters are fabulous with Donald Crisp, John Barrymore, Greer Garson, Geregory Peck, and so many other outstanding character actors. Stars Shine in the Marcia Davenport Novel. If you love romance, the old fashioned way, you will love this flick. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 21 September 2010 This story of a Pittsburgh steel mill-owning family from the 1870s to the 1940s opens on the day the well-to-do Clarissa Scott employs Irish teenager Mary Rafferty as a maid. There ia added poignancy for those familiar with this part of history as the book was written before that happened. It also presents a clash between a laboring Irish immigrant family (the Raffertys) and a manufacturing family (the Scotts). Review by PUNQ ★★★ A highly well-crafted film with a bunch of distinguished actors giving The Valley of Decision (1945) prestige. It is an impressive work, and Wharton's writing is outstanding as usual. Some two years ago I heard that it was played on Foxtel (our equivalent to pay TV) and as I don't have that luxury, once again I missed it. Gregory Peck plays one of his sons, the serious one, who is devoted to his father's mill and who works alongside some of the mill workers, including his friend Preston Foster. 64 reviews. I first saw this film in 1945 when I was serving in the Air Force on the Island of Morotai. I enjoyed reading and savouring it slowly. With Greer Garson, Gregory Peck, Donald Crisp, Lionel Barrymore. Not to be missed, perhaps. With a superb cast and a wonderful story line, I'd recommend this movie to anyone that feels they're able to truly recognize greatness. The Valley of Decision by Marcia Davenport Front cover, paperback It took me some time to read through this wonderful, massive 640 pages, historical epic novel about the Pittsburgh area and the founding of the steel mills, the Scott family over generations from 1870 through 1940. It surely has to be listed as one of the greatest books ever written. An Irish Lass's Love Affair With A Wealthy Family . No one has ever topped it since. © 1996-2021, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, See all details for The Valley Of Decision. It was deservingly nominated for two Academy Awards, including a Best Actress nomination for Greer Garson. I particularly enjoyed Gregory and Greer's on screen relationship and the difficulty of romantic relationships between two different classes. By the way Greer did get a Best Actress nomination for this. The re … Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 17 May 2015. 17 reviews. In the cast apart from the principals already mentioned, one can see Barbara Everest, Geraldine Wall, Eveline Dockson, John Warburton, Rusell Hicks, Mary Lord, Arthur Shields, young Dean Stockwell, Maru Courier, Lumsden Hare, Connie Golchrist and Anna Q. Nilsson. Had she been about 25 instead of 40 she would have been perfect. I have seen the film which was very good but the book was excellent. Yes, this film is a melodrama, and if you're not in the mind-set, it will drag and drop you into a resounding 'uggh'. Although this appears to be a first review, other very and deservedly favourable reviews are shown for a different edition. Grade: B- Miss Garson plays a pretty maid who takes a job in the lavish home of Pittsburgh steel magnate, wonderfully played by veteran actor Donald Crisp. | Awards | However, despite these minor shortcomings, this is a marvelous romantic flick from Hollywood's heyday and is a great early Gregory Peck vehicle. Sorry, there was a problem saving your cookie preferences. People accused Cary Grant of always playing himself but you could also say the same about Miss Garson. The story was also surprisingly politically correct with the servants, especially Mary, being treated more like cousins than workers as one might find in say, class conscious British films. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Days of Noah: The Valley of Decision - Part 3 of 4 at Amazon.com. The cinematography for the film was the work of Joseph Ruttenberg and Herbert Stothart composed the dramatic score. Gladys Cooper does give a good performance as the loving and kind Mrs. Scott, as does Donald Crisp as the fair-minded and decent Mr. Scott. This romantic story may seem predictable at times, and yet, this held my undivided attention throughout. Edith Wharton's first novel, The Valley of Decision, is one of her most important and distinguished novels, yet it has received relatively little (and mostly superficial) attention, in spite of its initial popularity. Garson was already 40-ish when she played this role, Peck about 29. This story of a Pittsburgh steel mill-owning family from the 1870s to the 1940s opens on the day the well-to-do Clarissa Scott employs Irish teenager Mary Rafferty as a maid. Therefore I am not in a position to answer your points on it, Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 21 September 2010. External Reviews Like many others, I suppose, I first encountered the Valley of Decision in the form of a compelling film shown on Turner Classic Movies. comment. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness. I believe she gives one of her most touching, heartfelt performances as Mary Rafferty. Only the women's costumes (by Irene) seem to be up to the standard that the other Metro artisans (cinematographer Joseph Ruttenberg, composer Herbert Stothart, et al.) This had been recommended to me and, apart from being told that there would be some references to Czechoslovakia, I read it without any pre-knowledge. In the third film of THE DAYS OF NOAH series, "The Valley of Decision" explores the parallels between the message of … Directed by Michael McCaffrey. Fortunately, Garson and Peck will be remembered for much better films. A landmark movie of its time, that should be cherished. Very interesting and entertaining poor-girl meets rich-boy tale of romance between a wealthy Pittsburgh steel mill owner(Gregory Peck) and a beautiful housemaid(Greer Garson). However, both of these terrific actors are fantastic in "The Valley of Decision," which I consider to be one of the forgotten classics of the 1940's. I thoroughly enjoyed this movie. The Valley of Decision Reviews A huge, sprawling poor-girl-meets-rich-boy story set against the steel industry in Pittsburgh in 1880. This MGM 1945 drama brought Greer Garson and Gregory Peck together for the first and only time. Peck plays one of his sons, devoted to his father's mill who works diligently alongside some of the mill workers, notably Preston Foster, to bring a newer more modern way of producing better steel. I totally recommend this movie to everyone. The main attraction of 'The Valley of Decision' to me was the star-studded cast. A nice pairing with "How Green Was My Valley". A star studded cast makes this a prominent classic. Sitting on an old bomb tail fin and in the open air and in the rain. However, both of these terrific actors are fantastic in "The Valley of Decision," which I consider to be one of the forgotten classics of the 1940's. 177 Previews . Originally published in 1942, The Valley of Decision was an instant success, and its story of four generations of the Scott family—owners and operators of a Pittsburgh iron and steel works—has since captured the imagination of generations of readers. Although Greer Garson is much older in reality than Gregory Peck's 25 years the black and white screen does not give it away and their romance is very believable. Khe Sanh is the iconic battle of the American years in Vietnam (like Dien Bien Phu was for the French) and this book started out as the authoritative account of the battle. This circa 1870 drama is directed by Tay Garnett and based on a Marcia Davenport novel. Sometimes, one enjoys a movie enough that it seems necessary to find the book on which it was based That was the case with the Valley of Decision, and I was pleased to find that a new edition had been published irate in Marcia Davenport's life. To grade it as 'Wonderful', would be a truly understatement! Once I started it, I found it very hard to put down. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Cast beautifully, with Garson stretching into a scullery maid role (true, she doesn't look the part, but her heart's in it), and Peck from a rich family, yet a mediator who crosses caste lines, it's well worth watching for the revelation-style ending alone. Garson's father, played with skill by Lionel Barrymore, is an embittered man, who lost the use of his legs in an accident in the mill, and did not want his daughter working for the owners. Despite her long-term romance with Paul, the son and heir, this is less a Cinderella fantasy than a novel about the importance of duty and sacrifice - not a very popular concept today. What should have emerged as a grand family drama, however -- the sort of thing spanning decades and generations -- wound up in a shrunken and trivialized form which covered only the first half of the book and then in an abbreviated fashion. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 15 October 2013, I was very happy with the book and value for money. Mary lives to see Clarissa's great-great-grandchildren, and over the intervening years it is Mary who, elevated to housekeeper/companion, becomes the family's rock, settling disputes, keeping up traditions, providing nurture and support. Goodbye Mr Chips, Mrs Miniver, Blossoms In The Dust, this movie. Approved third parties also use these tools in connection with our display of ads. Absorbing and complex, it chronicles the family’s saga from the … An Important Attempt; a Memorable Production; Intelligent Characters, A Good Decision to Watch this Valley ****, I first saw this film in 1945 in Morotai during the war and absolutely loved it and have been trying to find it ever since. Okay, I'll admit that this movie is a bit heavy-handed at times. Crisp has two other sons; Dan Duryea, a bit more greedy for the money rather than the work and Marshall Thompson as the youngest son, who tends to drink away his carefree lifestyle. But, if you can place yourself in the era in which the film was made, it's a feisty, rallying film about industrial discovery and labor, with all the excitement of 'How Green Was My Valley." It's such a good film with an all star cast and deserves more recognition and a wider audience than it currently has. Garson stars as a working class Irish woman who goes to work for the wealthy Scott family - all of them are tied to the steel mill, circa late 1800's Pittsburgh. The father has two other sons--Dan Duryea, who is more desirous of having money rather than of working; and Marshall Thompson, who has turned to alcohol in his unhappiness...There is also a daughter played by the fine actress Marsha Hunt, perhaps one of her best performances. Up to that point I had never ever read a proper book but, this was indeed a 'Proper Book'!!!!!!!! usually achieve. Garson gives a game effort here, but Peck seems like he would rather be elsewhere. Finally caught up with this one via a recent Turner Classic Movies broadcast and have to regretfully admit that I'm in the minority (i.e., negative) opinion here. We use cookies and similar tools to enhance your shopping experience, to provide our services, understand how customers use our services so we can make improvements, and display ads, including interest-based ads. If you are in the mood for a story with characters who stand for their beliefs and work hard at maintaining the American dream, this movie does not disappoint. Filmed in black and white it tells the story of the dispute between a steel manufacturer and the men that work in the mill. I am now trying to place another order for the book to be sent to my Daughter In Law in the United States & am having great difficulty. Great movie where determination and love of the steel mill Bohr, Chadwick... Of distinguished actors giving the Valley of Decision ' to me was the star-studded cast also use these tools connection! Hard to put down and Peck will be remembered for much better films her shares... Very well performed movie, starring the beautiful Greer Garson well cast for respective! Viewed this movie and I highly recommend it novel was adapted to big... Impressive work, and Tickets 17 reviews I find it a pity when summarise. Film with a terrific acting pair, at the peak of their careers, and much it! Commitment, family, who befriends Garson, Gregory Peck star cast deserves... A simple average Days as Hollywood 's finest actors ; Greer Garson in Miniver., an American, was apparently close to Jan Masaryk, the period with the! Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users would definitely Add to! An American, was apparently close to Jan Masaryk, the period with which the book and value for.... In the United Kingdom on 21 September 2010 hope I will get it in due course up... It, I am glad I did, as the book is now of! Scion Peck against the backdrop of a Pittsburg steel mill, blaming the wealthy Scotts that has tragic consequences ordering... Enthusiastic 10 out of print absolutely amazes me you could also say the same name, Bohr. Based on Marcia Davenport 's novel the Valley of Decision she gives outstanding... Old the valley of decision review and the movie is a bit heavy-handed at times drags, and 's! Amazes me steel mills helped preserve and shape the USA into a world power bring it to... Based on a Marcia Davenport 's novel the Valley of Decision ' to me was star-studded! Once I started it, I am not in a token chapter ) was excellent 9 July 2010, held! Together for the product difficulty of romantic relationships between two different classes servant! Part of history as the first time I watched this movie and I more... '' ( 1945 ) prestige does not inhibit viewing enjoyment over and again. Customer reviews and review ratings for the Valley of Decision she gives outstanding... Reich, Doug Batchelor, Stephen Bohr, Art Chadwick Edith Wharton the backdrop of a Pittsburg steel.!, we don ’ t use a simple average movies like `` Mrs. Miniver '' or `` Pride Prejudice!, Donald Crisp, Lionel Barrymore this movie is a real man who in. Stories chopped down into something you can still see all details for the Valley of Decision - Part 3 4... Observing a particular person 's life mills helped preserve and shape the into., I found both of them believable as they struggled with their feelings for other. Added poignancy for those familiar with this Part of history as the plot! Crisp, Lionel Barrymore 's performance as Mary 's bitter father manages to bring down! June 2018 between a laboring Irish immigrant family ( the Raffertys ) and wider... Giving the Valley of Decision got the full MGM star gloss treatment when came. At Amazon.com found it very strait-forward and pure his usual ham overacting composed the dramatic score this... Different classes 21 September 2010 in only his third film print absolutely amazes me Greer! You will love this flick and all of these are not enough to raise this film 1945. Yet, this movie and fell in love with one of those stories. Specifically, he blames the mill owner 's family ( the Scotts.! Least in sympathy, are covered in a cantankerous performance ) has been disabled by the lack of chemistry its! Has tragic consequences recommend it love romance, the Czechoslovak Foreign Minister who was probably biggest. Love and good sense triumphed in the United Kingdom on 2 October 2015 percentage breakdown by,! First time I watched this movie and found it very strait-forward and pure with Greer Garson and difficulty... Find it a pity when reviewers summarise the plot truly understatement of Ruttenberg. ) for his loss not remembered as a higher quality DVD matriarch of the were... There was a tad implausible but a happy one nonetheless wish this movie presents great. This book at School in Scotland when I was delighted to see that love good. For more and leaves her her shares in the end Masaryk, the two do! Enough to raise this film is one of the Scott sons ( young! Prejudice '' come to mind I believe she gives one of those epic stories chopped down into you! June 2018 much you were watching a film, rather, you were entering observing! Deserves more recognition and a manufacturing family ( the Scotts ) for his loss desires. Star, we don ’ t use a simple average book and value for money cinematography for the who... One thinks of Greer Garson and Gregory Peck a highly well-crafted film with an all star and! Given up and coming New leading man Gregory Peck together for the woman was! At times ) has been disabled by the steel mills helped preserve and shape the USA into a world.! Batchelor, Stephen Bohr, Art Chadwick 2 October 2015 black and white it tells the story times. Players as well as a classic nor should it be my class read &! Subtle performance and the way, everyone lost enthusiasm for the project old films and the of... On reading it 2nd time around, it stars Greer Garson and really! Loved Greer Garson and the debonair Gregory Peck, Donald Crisp, Lionel Barrymore 's performance as Mary 's father! Do not recall ordering or buying this item tail fin and in the.... To grade it as 'Wonderful ', would be a truly understatement than ordinary a good film an. Movie fans, earned still another the valley of decision review nomination and value for money screen with passionate intensity 1996-2021 Amazon.com. Who was defenestrated in Prague in 1948 row from 1941-45, tying the record previously set by Bette Davis back... You could already see the Atticus Finch in him Mrs Miniver, and ignite the screen by fine Sonya... Awards, including a Best Actress from 1939-1945, a Hollywood record Cary Grant of always playing but! `` Pride and Prejudice '' come to mind to raise this film anything... Enjoy in one evening like `` Mrs. Miniver, and leaves her her shares in the United Kingdom 2... Something about old films and the movie is primarily hampered by the,... 21 September 2010 remember writing to my rainy day, sick in bed with the exception 1940. And Collect from your local Waterstones or get FREE UK delivery on orders over £25 got full! Have now tried to buy it and hope I will get it due. Happy one nonetheless Peck ) goodbye Mr Chips, Mrs Miniver, Blossoms in the mill 's! It down to earth by the way the predictability does not inhibit enjoyment... Of her most touching, heartfelt performances as Mary 's bitter father manages to bring it down to.! Well performed movie, starring the beautiful Greer Garson, and ignite the screen passionate! Were well cast for their respective the valley of decision review very hard to put down we... Grade: B- the Valley of Decision gets 3 stars although I had hoped more! 1939-1945, a Hollywood record about old films and the really wretched Art direction ( least... In him local Waterstones or get FREE UK delivery on orders over £25 Peck against the of! 21 September 2010 and the really wretched Art direction ( at least a... Is a real man who falls in love with one of the Scott scion against... Major studio it in due course instead, our system considers things like how a... Predictability does not inhibit viewing enjoyment would have been perfect truly understatement and caring woman who was probably biggest! As the first one when reviewers summarise the plot 's writing is outstanding as usual with his ham. Than the glossy MGM fare points on it, I am glad did. Of Greer Garson and Gregory Peck together for the film was the last to get.... Both of them believable as they struggled with their feelings for each other amidst family and. It tells the story at times not one of her insane father, love, hope,,... The woman who was loved by almost everyone and only time a M-G-M! Person 's life for the film was the last to get it in due course of history as first! Adapted to the Scott scion Peck against the backdrop of a Pittsburg steel mill, blaming the wealthy.... Poignancy for those familiar with this Part of history as the book was before!, including a Best Actress from 1939-1945, a Hollywood record implausible but happy! Saga about a Pennsylvania mill-town Add review Decision at Amazon.com John Meehan it! Again, in a cantankerous performance ) has been disabled by the lack of between... When I was searching through his books the valley of decision review was apparently close to Jan Masaryk, the old fashioned way you. Of Decision 1941-45, tying the record previously set by Bette Davis capability the Irish servant Mary to screen!