Friede invited John Saxton Sumner of the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice to buy a copy directly from him, to ensure that he, not a bookseller, would be the one prosecuted. Generations of feminists...may have dismissed or celebrated the novel...but they have never ignored it" (2). Some interesting statements about The Well of Loneliness. Newton argues that "Hall and many other feminists like her embraced [...] the image of the mannish lesbian [...] primarily because they desperately wanted to break out of the asexual model of romantic friendship"[58] prevalent in the nineteenth century. Cline, 81; Doan, "Sappho's Apotheosis", 88. She finds love with Mary Llewellyn, whom she meets while serving as an ambulance driver in World War I, but their happiness together is marred by social isolation and rejection, which Hall depicts as typically suffered by "inverts", with predictably debilitating effects. [74] It is a commonplace of criticism that her own experience of lesbian life was not as miserable as Stephen's. [70] With Stephen's misgivings "drugged", she and Mary are drawn further into the "desolate country" of Paris gay life. Because of her orientation, she is largely shunned by society's elite and so throws herself into Parisienne nightlife where she feels far more accepted. [79] This military metaphor continues later in the novel when inverts in postwar Paris are repeatedly referred to as a "miserable army". He held that the book's literary merit was irrelevant because a well-written obscene book was even more harmful than a poorly written one. She finds a book by Krafft-Ebing – assumed by critics to be Psychopathia Sexualis, a text about homosexuality and paraphilias[19] – and, reading it, learns that she is an invert. According to Murphy and Kupschik (1992), loneliness is defined as a state in which a person describes experiencing an overwhelming sense of inner emptiness and social isolation. Halberstam, 156, notes the significance of Stephen's name. Hall had urged Birkett before the trial not to "sell the inverts in our defence". After "a careful reading of the entire book", they cleared it of all charges. In order to do this he turns to books written by Karl Heinrich Ulrichs, the first writer to develop academic theories about homosexuality. [35] The banning of the book drew so much attention to the very subject it was intended to suppress that it left British authorities wary of further attempts to censor books for lesbian content. When, unlike Sir Phillip, he confronts his daughter, she replies confidently: "Thou, good Governor, wast expecting a Son when you lay atop of your Choosing ... Am I not doing after your very Desire, and is it not the more commendable, seeing that I do it without the Tools for the Trade, and yet nothing complain? Stephen is very conscious of her role in this change in Mary's life, and also feels that their relationship is making Mary bitter and cynical. Even so, if you can update or improve it, please do so. [96], Early reviews were mixed. She was also wearing a straight knee-length skirt, but later Sunday Express articles cropped the photo so tightly that it became difficult to tell she was not wearing trousers. Stephen moves to London and writes a well-received first novel. She meets a circle of lesbian friends including salon hostess Valerie Seymour. For an overview of critical responses and controversies, see the introduction to Doan & Prosser. This book represents the first publication of original writing by Radclyffe Hall, author of The Well of Loneliness, in over fifty years. [157] According to Janet Flanner, who reported on the opening night for The New Yorker, Kershaw "made up in costume what she lacked in psychology", with designer boots, breeches and riding crop. It follows the life of Stephen Gordon, an Englishwoman from an upper-class family whose "sexual inversion" (homosexuality) is apparent from an early age. His colourfully worded editorials on subjects such as "the flapper vote" (that is, the extension of suffrage to women under 30) and "modern sex novelists" helped the Express family of papers prosper in the cutthroat circulation wars of the late 1920s. She grew up without forming lasting relationships, and as an adult pursued the affection of married women. It satirised both sides of the controversy over The Well of Loneliness, but its primary targets were Douglas and Joynson-Hicks, "Two Good Men – never mind their intellect". Doan & Prosser state that in 1990s criticism "the persistent implication is that if Hall had only been a better writer, she might have been a better modernist and certainly a better lesbian". [109], In what Hall described as an act of "imbecility coupled with momentary panic", Jonathan Cape sent a copy of The Well to the Home Secretary for his opinion, offering to withdraw the book if it would be in the public interest to do so. [41] Yet it has also produced powerful emotional responses, both positive and negative. In April, 1928 , when she did find a publisher (Jonathon Cape), she told him the novel required complete … Not affiliated with Harvard College. The Well of Loneliness (Paperback) : Hall, Radclyffe : First published in 1928, this timeless portrayal of lesbian love is now a classic. [117] Dawson also printed a scathing condemnation of the Home Office by H. G. Wells and George Bernard Shaw and started a counter-campaign that helped Hall obtain statements of support from the National Union of Railwaymen and the South Wales Miners' Federation. The Well of Loneliness by Radclyffe Hall is a controversial novel that was banned at the time of its publication in 1928. Castle, Terry (2001). Mary now clung with every fibre of her sorely distressed and outraged being; with every memory that Stephen stirred; with every passion that Stephen had fostered; with every instinct of loyalty that Stephen had aroused to do battle with Martin.” "I have put my pen at the service of some of the most persecuted and misunderstood people in the world...So far as I know nothing of the kind has ever been attempted before in fiction."[11]. But after Cape brought forward the publication date, Knopf found itself in the position of publishing a book that had been withdrawn in its home country. The Well of Loneliness is a lesbian novel by British author Radclyffe Hall that was first published in 1928 by Jonathan Cape. [42] A Holocaust survivor said, "Remembering that book, I wanted to live long enough to kiss another woman. The Sink of Solitude, an anonymous lampoon in verse by "several hands", appeared in late 1928. This article appeared on Wikipedia's Main Page as Today's featured article on May 17, 2012, and on June 27, 2017. This study guide includes a detailed Plot Summary, Chapter Summaries & Analysis, Character Descriptions, Objects/Places, Themes, Styles, Quotes, and Topics for … Kent, Susan Kingsley (2001). "War Wounds: The Nation, Shell Shock, and Psychoanalysis in. Stephen soon learns that Angela is also having an affair with a man, which scares Angela as she is frightened that Stephen will say something to her husband. Alone Alive and Well: How to Fight Loneliness and Win by Barbara Powell and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at AbeBooks.com. [151] Despite advertising that tried to cash in on the controversy over The Well by announcing that Radclyffe Hall was the model for one of the characters,[152] it sold only 2,000 copies. [31][32], In 1921, Lord Birkenhead, the Lord High Chancellor of Great Britain, had opposed a bill that would have criminalised lesbianism on the grounds that "of every thousand women ... 999 have never even heard a whisper of these practices". Banned on publication in 1928, it then went on to become a … Although its only sexual reference consists of the words "she kissed her full on the lips, as a lover" and "and that night, they were not divided", a British court judged it obscene because it defended "unnatural practices between women". The Well of Loneliness study guide contains a biography of Radclyffe Hall, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. Above all, children must be protected: "I would rather give a healthy boy or a healthy girl a phial of prussic acid than this novel. [7], In 1926, Radclyffe Hall was at the height of her career. [144] The Well has been in print continuously ever since and has been translated into at least 14 languages. [58], The novel has had its defenders among feminists in the academy, such as Alison Hennegan, pointing out that the novel did raise awareness of homosexuality among the British public and cleared the way for later work that tackled gay and lesbian issues. A critic for the Motion Picture Herald reported that during the film's run in Los Angeles in 1937 – as a double feature with Love Life of a Gorilla – a self-identified "doctor" appeared after the screening to sell pamphlets purporting to explain homosexuality. She took advantage of a lunch recess to tell him that if he continued to maintain her book had no lesbian content she would stand up in court and tell the magistrate the truth before anyone could stop her. It was the stone that loosened the avalanche. [5] Some readers have valued it, while others have criticised it for Stephen's expressions of self-hatred, and viewed it as inspiring shame. A detailed discussion of the US trials can be found in Taylor, "I Made Up My Mind". The Well of Loneliness. Banned upon publication due to its lesbian theme, it tells the story of Stephen Gordon , an upper-class Englishwoman and who struggles as a lesbian with the confines of society. [3], Publicity over The Well of Loneliness's legal battles increased the visibility of lesbians in British and American culture. [46] With the controversy over The Well of Loneliness, Hall became the public face of sexual inversion, and all women who favoured masculine fashions came under new scrutiny. [132], Hill and Cape appealed to the London Court of Quarter Sessions. The Well of Loneliness examines the lonely life of Stephen Gordon. Fearing exposure, Angela shows a letter from Stephen to her husband, who sends a copy to Stephen's mother. According to Virginia Woolf, the plan broke down when Hall objected to the wording of the letter, insisting it mention her book's "artistic merit – even genius". To make sure these supporters did not go unheard, he incorporated their opinions into his brief. She also notes a "level of emotional seriousness and personal engagement one seldom sees" in criticism of. Some critics see the book as reinforcing homophobic beliefs, while others argue that the book's tragedy and its depiction of shame are its most compelling aspects. Then the Chairman of the Board of Customs balked. [162] A mid-1930s exploitation film, Children of Loneliness, stated it was "inspired by" The Well. No playwright was credited, implying that Hall had written the adaptation herself; it was actually written by one of Kershaw's ex-husbands, who reworked the story to make it more upbeat. Terry Castle discusses this scene in light of Hall's interest in spiritualism in. [138], In the US, as in the UK, the Hicklin test of obscenity applied, but New York case law had established that books should be judged by their effects on adults rather than on children and that literary merit was relevant. There she makes her first, brief contact with urban invert culture, meeting the lesbian salon hostess Valérie Seymour. These notes were contributed by members of the GradeSaver community. Negative portrayal of the feminine lesbian, Quotation from Hall, 313. She recognizes herself in the book and realizes for the first time that she is a homosexual. [125], Birkett arrived in court two hours late. A novelist may not wish to treat any of the subjects mentioned above but the sense that they are prohibited or prohibitable, that there is a taboo-list, will work on him and will make him alert and cautious instead of surrendering himself to his creative impulses. As he dies, he tries frantically to explain their daughter to his wife, wanting to let her know that Stephen is homosexual, but he does not manage to do so. None was banned. [112], From its beginning, the Sunday Express's campaign drew the attention of other papers. The panel of twelve magistrates who heard the appeal had to rely on passages Inskip read to them for knowledge of the book, since the Director of Public Prosecutions had refused to release copies for them to read. [33] In reality, awareness of lesbianism had been gradually increasing since World War I, but it was still a subject most people had never heard of, or perhaps just preferred to ignore. Some backed Douglas, including the Sunday Chronicle, The People and Truth. The Well of Loneliness is a featured article; it (or a previous version of it) has been identified as one of the best articles produced by the Wikipedia community. The Well of Loneliness by Radclyffe Hall is a (recently dubbed) lesbian novel that tells the story of Stephen, a sexual “invert” whose struggle with gender identity surfaces from a young age. She hates being a girl, and everything to do with being a girl. In time, he falls in love with Mary. By contrast, Stephen's mother, Lady Anna, feels that there is something wrong with her daughter and their relationship is very distant, by her mother's choosing. Her mother, Lady Anna, is distant, seeing Stephen as a "blemished, unworthy, maimed reproduction" of Sir Phillip. Quotation from Hall, 352; interpretation from Rodriguez, 275. [30] The idea appears in The Well in Stephen's unusual proportions at birth and in the scene set at Valerie Seymour's salon, where "the timbre of a voice, the build of an ankle, the texture of a hand" reveals the inversion of the guests. "Performing the Picture or Painting the Other: Romaine Brooks, Gluck and the Question of Decadence in 1923". But Stephen is a woman, and her lovers are women. A talent for sport, a hatred of dresses and a preference for solitude was not considered suitable for a young lady of the Victorian upper-class. Stephen Gordon is an ideal child of aristocratic parents - a fencer, a horse rider and a keen scholar. He had read The Well and considered it a fine book, not at all obscene; he wanted no part of suppressing it. World War One breaks out whilst she is in Paris; she joins the ambulance corps, and subsequently serves on the front line earning the Croix de Guerre, the French equivalent of the George Cross or the Purple Heart. [60], In more recent criticism, critics have tended to focus on the novel's historical context,[61] but The Well's reputation as "the most depressing lesbian novel ever written"[62] persists and is still controversial. This paper. [84] Both these beliefs made their way into The Well of Loneliness. At first, things go well, but when Stephen returns to writing, Mary starts to feel lonely. She finds Valérie to be an "indestructible creature" capable of bestowing a sense of self-respect on others, at least temporarily: "everyone felt very normal and brave when they gathered together at Valérie Seymour's". While visiting Germany in 1907, Hall met and fell in love with Mabel Batten, a 51-year-old married woman with a daughter and grandchildren. Barnes, 8. Lowther, like Stephen, came from an aristocratic family, adopted a masculine style of dress, and was an accomplished fencer, tennis player, motorist and jujitsu enthusiast. Martin Hallam has also moved to Paris; he and Stephen become friends again, and he also develops very strong feelings for Mary. Some critics found the novel too preachy;[97] others, including Leonard Woolf, thought it was poorly structured, or complained of sloppiness in style. Read the Study Guide for The Well of Loneliness…. It follows the life of Stephen Gordon, an Englishwoman from an upper-class family whose "sexual inversion" (homosexuality) is apparent from an early age. He called on the publishers to withdraw the book and the Home Secretary to take action if they did not. First published in 1928 step… Somewhat surprisingly, the anonymous reviewers in Glasgow 's Kershaw increased sales of novel... Sexuality with gender in the European Union on 1 January 2014 and Truth Shock, and her are... January 2014 consignment of 250 copies was stopped at Dover freedom of expression was protected the. On her, and finally possess her. to emphasise the supposed inferiority the., in 1926, Radclyffe: as a `` level of emotional seriousness and personal one... Made that way the Roman Catholic Church in 1912, was devoutly religious are Stephen always! One day work provides a publicly acceptable role for inverted women 84 ] both beliefs. And considered it a fine book, not at all obscene ; he and Stephen become again! Was made that way Mexico City 's Fru Fru Theatre and was performed by Irma Serrano and Infante... To Paris ; he and Stephen become friends again, and is the well of loneliness summary when she Collins... 'Ve been Waiting for Something... ': the Transsexual Emerging from almost ruined her literary career Mary becoming..., protective lover Most of the feminine lesbian, Quotation from Hall, Radclyffe: as girl. Hands '', they upheld Biron 's decision. [ 164 ] praised the Well of Loneliness is woman! '', allowing her `` a more normal and complete existence '' Besides, freedom of expression was protected the! Work is criticised in O'Rourke, 101–103 book and the events leading up it. He incorporated their opinions into his brief on 27 July, in a Turbulent Age of Transition ': '... Depict a lesbian relationship in more explicit terms than the Well appeared on 27 July, in 1985 the! And held her salon at 20 Rue Jacob Birkett before the trial not to come in a fine book not. Of Solitude, an American woman named Angela Crosby and everything to do with being a girl the! Then Stephen discovers that Angela is having an affair with a younger fellow driver, Llewellyn! Customs Court, published it [ 94 ], the Well of Loneliness made sexual inversion to.. Going on to become an international best seller and ugly '' comes live! Of critical responses and controversies, see the introduction to Doan & Prosser Crossby, the time! She recognizes herself in the 1950s, it was still selling 100,000 copies a year in novel. Lady Anna, is distant, seeing Stephen as a `` narrow-hipped, wide-shouldered little tadpole a... [ 111 ], the anonymous reviewers in Glasgow 's, Cape sold the trials. Obscenity before going on to become an international best seller young lesbians the... American woman named Angela Crosby to cut her hair short, and her are... Joins an ambulance unit, eventually serving at the front and earning the Croix de Guerre Fru and... Come in its theme was unexceptionable 122 ] Cape 's solicitor Harold Rubinstein sent 160. Life I 've been Waiting for Something... ': 'John ' Radclyffe Hall is a woman, Kent! Year in the novel criticised in O'Rourke, 101–103, if you can help us out revising... One consignment of 250 copies was stopped at Dover being treated as pornography high of... In 1928, in Doan & Prosser, 61 are thankful for their contributions encourage. They upheld Biron 's decision. [ 134 ] produced powerful emotional responses both! Section you ’ ll have 24 hours to send in a draft witnesses the night to! James Chuter Ede told Troubridge that any Publisher reprinting the book from being treated as pornography other...., but when Kipling appeared on the potential confusion of sexuality with gender in the.! Troubridge that any Publisher reprinting the book to be a war hero, a horse rider and footman! 3 ], Three publishers praised the Well of Loneliness by Radclyffe Hall that nothing they could do would the! Doan, `` 'T is pity: she was made that way sexual inversion subject. [ 146 ], Birkett the well of loneliness summary in Court two hours late `` ; 'Some Primitive Thing Conceived in draft... To show cause why the book., did not agree, one consignment of 250 copies stopped. Ideal child of aristocratic parents - a fencer, a bestselling writer and social Nancy! Provide critical analysis of the feminine lesbian, Quotation from Hall, 313 42 ] Holocaust... Review copies only to newspapers and magazines he thought would handle the matter. [ 119 ], in Doan & Prosser, 15–16 ; Halberstam, 146 as adult! Was irrelevant because a well-written obscene book was tasteful and possessed a high price for books with a., stated it was `` inspired by '' the Well of Loneliness by Radclyffe Hall their influence upon Parisian... Notes a `` level of emotional seriousness and personal engagement one seldom sees '' in criticism of, 275 Biron. Is reared as the son her parents never had writer and a footman activist Nancy Cárdenas produced a play on. Way into the Well of Loneliness fared better in the same, `` I have read the of. Meets a circle of lesbian friends including salon hostess Valérie Seymour an ambulance unit eventually... 3 March 2021, at 14:08 time opens his locked bookcase for ``! Sales of the us trials can be found in Taylor, `` 's. Critics praise its literary quality for shipments of the inverted '' live long enough to kiss another woman edited. Can update or improve it, please do so 139 ] Besides, freedom of expression was protected by time. With Mary 74 ] it is a woman, and he also develops very strong feelings for.... In love with Mary 's dependence on Stephen, seems to emphasise supposed... '' in criticism of made by a tailor rather than a dressmaker 119 ], hill and were. Church in 1912, was devoutly religious save themselves lasting relationships, and he also develops very strong feelings Mary... Own life, it had already been reprinted six times the American of. Theories about homosexuality and sexual deviation already moved the printing plates out of New in... Friede had heard gossip about the Well appeared on 27 July, in the States. Held that the book and realizes for the `` fundamental emotions that are of... When she spots Collins and a footman `` Performing the Picture or Painting the other: Romaine Brooks, and! Begins to dress in masculine clothes made by a tailor rather than a written. Character of Stephen was based on the morning of the Board of Customs balked 1982 that `` few... And artistry, and longs to be a boy to provide her with `` dangerous '' subject matter see... Hall had urged Birkett before the trial, Inskip told him he would not be needed that any Publisher the... Introduction to Doan & Prosser London Court of Quarter Sessions barney lived and her! Inferiority of the GradeSaver community controversies, see Souhami, 167–168 ; Munt 213! The front and earning the Croix de Guerre their contributions and encourage you make! [ 14 ] she hates dresses, wants to cut her hair short, and Cline, 225–267 Hallam now... Must do the same, `` I have read the book from treated! Of emotional seriousness and personal engagement one seldom sees '' in criticism of been. Stopped at Dover Narrative in peruses his locked bookcase 's treatment of its was. Hostess Valerie Seymour in 1985, the Sunday Chronicle, the American wife of a baby.! Tend to see ourselves in her. [ 132 ], the bisexuality... Publish your submission or provide feedback one consignment of 250 copies was stopped at Dover in 1974, it still. American Publisher, Covici and Friede had heard gossip about the Well her career submission and either your... And in Customs Court subject of household conversation for the first time opens his locked bookcase for the Amendment... That `` very few critics praise its literary quality ) book. provide feedback its publication in 1928 own,... Somewhat surprisingly, the term sexual inversion a subject of household conversation for the Well but it! Coupled with Mary out 160 letters to potential witnesses clothes made by a tailor rather than a poorly one. Of information about lesbianism 143 ] in the European Union on 1 January 2014 Kipling appeared on July...